Sunday, January 8, 2023

A Game Designer Walks Into NASA Astronaut Training • Jennifer Scheurle • YOW! 2019

Talking about why other industries should work with game designers!
...and what we can learn from how NASA works (i.e. Problem Briefs and Design Matrix).

Saturday, December 24, 2022

Keywords Studios Expansion

(as reported by Eurogamer.net)
Game development services supplier Keywords Studios grows its global workforce to 12,000 staff after the acquisition of AMC Studio in Romania. The Romanian studio expands Keywords' locations from Dublin, Katowice, Paris, and Milan. 

https://www.eurogamer.net/keywords-studios-opens-new-romanian-studio

Friday, September 30, 2022

Emotion in Games...

Bram Stoker's Dracula might seem like a strange source for illustrating the need to acknowledge emotion in games. I chose these quotes from Dracula for various reasons. The first, because 'horror' is one of the most enduring genres of human story telling, an experience that is both difficult to generate with subtlety and exquisite to experience as an entertainment. The modern horror genre in the media of fiction, film and games is indebted to and is perhaps exemplified by Stoker's unique creation and his ability as a storyteller. Dracula, is also an enduring inspiration for game designers attempts to create atmosphere and evoke some of our most primal emotions, fear, loathing, hope, redemption. And finally, I was inspired by a talk with Paul Conway, the Irish game designer and anchor of the team that created The Dark Side Detective, hugely successful point-and-click adventure puzzle humour (so many cross-overs) video game. Paul used the following quote to anchor the investor pitch for his upcoming game Eldritch House.

(Dr. Seward's Diary, 26 September.) 

"I want you to believe."

"To believe what?"

"To believe in things that you cannot. Let me illustrate. I heard once of an American who so defined faith: 'that faculty which enables us to believe things which we know to be untrue.' For one, I follow that man. He meant that we shall have an open mind, and not let a little bit of truth check the rush of a big truth, like a small rock does a railway truck. We get the small truth first. Good! We keep him, and we value him; but all the same we must not let him think himself all the truth in the universe."

Bram Stoker

I add the following to illustrate the author's word-craft, Stoker's talent for elevating the tension and sense of mystery. 

(Dr. Seward's Diary. 29 September, morning..)

"Un-Dead! Not alive! What do you mean? Is this all a nightmare, or what is it?"

"There are mysteries which men can only guess at, which age by age they may solve only in part. Believe me, we are now on the verge of one.

Bram Stoker

So, starting with an example of exemplary story-telling, the slow accretion of detail, the gradual illumination and revealing, of unveiling glimpses of the 'world' or 'game-world', a 'whole' world of characters and concepts, of history and lore. The storyteller creates a whole that intrigues, entices, and coheres over time to excite and instil wonder in the player/audience.

Storytelling is the central art of engaging game experiences, regardless or game genre (action, adventure, puzzler, open world, role-playing, strategy, sports). The storytelling can range over authorial (i.e. designed in, crafted narrative, scripted, a long-form prose), participative (where player/audience have some agency in shaping the story) through to emergent (where players create and produce their own narratives). 

In her 2011 GDC keynote Kellee Santiago (Venezuelan American video game designer and cofounder of thatgamecompany, publisher of Journey) stated that she believes that a game needs a message that captures the emotions at its core rather than chasing or being defined by technologies and features. The emotion, the message should be captured in a sentence or two and that, in itself, defines either or both the pitch for the game and/or its essential meaning. It acts as a touchstone against which ideas for inclusion may be judged. 

"Begin with the intent of your content and make it your guide," and pay attention to the artistry "music, imagery and story arc" rather than technology or features for technology's sake. They believe in a "holistic, experiential approach", to, in a way, let the game talk back to the designer. [1]

Achieving that stage, of talk back, of letting people respond to the gameplay and for development to respond to that feedback means getting people involved in testing prototypes, learning how they react and feel. The prototyping and testing approach is crucial when designing interactive experiences, but becomes even more important with multi-player, playing together and sharing experiences. Some aspects of a design really only emerge when you give players the controller.

In Journey, "Together we can move the mountain" started out as the underlying message of the game, but as it developed, as the gameplay and feel evolved they found that it "'was moving in a slightly different direction than was originally laid out. So they recast the message to "We all walk the path. Each journey is different.'" Interviews and press reaction also helped to shape the message, providing a testbed for vocabulary and key phrases for describing the game. [2]


Jenova Chen talked about the potential for games to engage player emotions, across the gamut of human experience. 


Prototyping for the emotional Journey actually began around its music. Chen said that he always does so because "music is the most effective and powerful medium that can create emotion." [6]




[1] Interview with Kellee Santiago (Christian Nutt, 2011) 

https://www.gamasutra.com/view/feature/134862/the_thatgamecompany_way.php


[2] Interview with Kellee Santiago (Mike Rose, 2011) 

https://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/36575/GDC_Europe_Design_Your_Game_Around_A_Message_Not_Features__Santiago.php


===========================================================================


Thatgamecompany founders Jenova Chen and Kellee Santiago had landed a three game contract with Sony, and guaranteeing access to the PlayStation platform and the marketing muscle of Sony (for flOw, Flower and Journey). Journey took three years from idea genesis to launching. And in the end? 

Jenova Chen stated, towards the end “A lot of people in our studio were not paid in the last half year, and we paid out all our savings,” Chen says. The company actually went bankrupt, at the time. “Was it really worth all this,” he asked? [5]



[3] Jenova Chen's Games for Change talk (Chen, 2014) G4C14: Jenova Chen / Blank Canvas Designing A New Era of Emotional Storytelling Through Games

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n_RKKuKvAvA


[4] In-Depth: Journey's rare and magical success (Alexander, 2012)

https://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/163143/InDepth_Journeys_rare_and_magical_success.php


[5] The journey to create Journey -- the quest for emotion (Sheffield, 2013)

https://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/186282/The_journey_to_create_Journey__the_quest_for_emotion.php


[6] GDC Video: Designing a new emotional experience in Journey (GDC Vault Staff, 2013)

https://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/191646/Video_Designing_a_new_emotional_experience_in_Journey.php



Notes: 

thatgamecompany producer Robin Hunicke (Journey, 2012)

Monday, September 6, 2021

Why Ireland for game development?

Niall O'Donoghue (The Washington Post) interviews game designers John and Brenda Romero about why they started their latest game studio "Romero Games" in Ireland in 2015. 

Gangster Capone character, dark lighting, wearing a hat, cigar in mouth.
“Empire of Sin,” a role-playing-strategy game directed by Brenda Romero, developed in Ireland, published by Paradox Interactive in 2020. Available on Steam, Microsoft Windows, MacOS, PlayStation 4, Xbox One, and Nintendo Switch.  See Romero Games - https://romerogames.com - for more.

John and Brenda Romero talk about what it is like living in Ireland, their family roots, Ireland's creative, cultural, scene, its stories and history. From a business perspective it was important to them that there was a local tech scene, but also a nascent game design scene and that reflects a deep appreciation for the art of games. Games are expressed through great stories and inspired by great locations (scenery, music, stories, arts and history). 

It was helpful that Ireland's national and local industry development agencies have a tradition of being accessible to entrepreneurs; that there is a positive attitude in Government agencies and among various gatekeepers to get things done in support of inward investment. There also foresee the potential for the industry in Ireland to grow and mature if there were greater supports for investing in start-up and SME initiatives were available (jobs, industry growth, spin-off benefits cultural arts). 

Yet they are puzzled by the absence of targeted tax supports for game development as an artistic creative industry sector. It prompts the question, is it possible that the Irish Government will develop something like the Section 481 Film Tax Credit for the Film/TV industry but targeting the Game Industry? Perhaps a new Section XXX Tax Credit Support scheme for investment in game title projects?

https://www.washingtonpost.com/video-games/2020/12/21/john-brenda-romero/

(access may be paywalled or registration required)


Tuesday, June 8, 2021

Diverse Games Much Needed

On The Creative Independent (from a conversation with Resham Mantri with Tanya DePass and B. Dave Walters - Game developers)

Do read this interview with Tanya DePass and Dave Walters on their work and experiences playing games, designing games, and seeing themselves (or not) being included in the game, in creating content, and telling a range of stories that matter. Focus on the criticism too, on building relationships and connections that matter, that are authentic, rather than casual (people will pick your brain for ideas and you never hear from them again - why not close the loop instead?)

"So don’t be that fair-weather friend. Be an honest collaborator. Get to know someone, see what it is they do and what you like about them. And forging a real bond is going to go way further than the occasional, “Oh, congrats," [Tanya]

https://thecreativeindependent.com/people/game-developers-tanya-depass-and-b-dave-walters-on-making-your-own-rules/

Thursday, April 22, 2021

The Game Design Essay (2021)

Game Design Essay (2021)

Essay - based on your final design brief, introduces some of the game design elements, narrative, research commentary with literature, industry history, context, etc.

This year's game essay will be a practical document encompassing your game design project. The essay explains your game design's inspiration and present some of your design ideas. The essay will also relates or position your design concept within the current market. You will identify audience, value and market factors and consider a plan for further development.  

Suggested structure for the essay:

Introduction: An introduction to the game design project (inspiration). 
Literature/commentary: Write a short research commentary including a small number of relevant references from research literature, ludography, related games, history and context, etc.
Provide a text box with a written sample of the game narrative, its backstory or lore.
Provide a small number of illustrations, mood-board, drawings, figures, diagrams. Please use the appendix for providing more detailed design elements if desired.
Discussion: Write a short section as a business pitch and plan for Spiel/Kickstarter. 
Conclusion: Conclude 
References:
Appendix:
No set word-count. 8 pages max (including illustrations, tables, etc.)
Appendix is not included in the page-count.
Choose your own reference style.

You can think of the Game Design Essay as a description summarising the proposed game, including the artistic, project, technical, and commercial elements. The document is not the game itself, it is rather, all the related information about the game that another designer, an investor or publisher, would like to know about the game. The information in the essay would probably address most of the questions a reviewer would have about the game.

Pitch warm-up

---------

In a sentence “It’s like…”

Single player, multiplayer, puzzle, builder, collaborative, cooperative, competitive, open-world, sandbox etc?

Family/Adult, player age, number of players, time to play. Casual vs campaigning etc. 

Background research

----------

Inspiration? 

Genre?

Related titles in this genre? 

Published influences, related and similar titles (even, if you look for it, references in the game literature!!!!) 

Design structural elements

--------

Game design elements? Gamifications?

Outcomes? Win/lose? Display/sharing?

The application of emotion principles?

The application of the uncertainty principles?

Narrative backdrop constructed by the design

Narrative potential constructed by the players

Complexity, scope? Too much, too little?  

Developer perspective

------

Paper prototype or mockups?

Any playtest feedback?

Comment on ease to ‘onboard’ new players? Simple version, complex version. House rules.

Identified ideal player types, market segment? Appeals to who?

Market perspective

-------

Potential to adapt or expand, levels, extent, add-ons, expansions? Is it a platform.

Market size of equivalent or similar titles?

Route to market? (publisher, self-publish, kickstarter, crowdfund)

Packaging/presentation? (box, components, online, platforms) look and feel.

Countries/languages? Cultural fit. Suggest markets. 

Product Production: Value, costs, price, effort

--------

Price-point/Pricing? Cost to design/develop?

Cost to service/operate?

IP or licensing questions?

Potential to rebrand or repurpose the ‘engine’ to another genre?

Monday, April 19, 2021

Persona driven design process

Model users: 'personas'

In following up on the topic of Persona driven design processes, we wanted to highlight that the WCAG Guidelines actually provide example personas for designer. "Stories of Web Users" offer character centred scenarios. While not actual persons nor comprehensively addressing every kind of disability, the characters illustrate and challenge designers to consider users with a range of needs and goals. https://www.w3.org/WAI/people-use-web/user-stories/

Personas offer a cast of synthetic characters complete with values, personal histories, needs and goals. Personas are not average demographic 'types', they are individual characters whose biographical detail allows designers to 'imagine' the persona's individual aspirations, choices and behaviour as realistic, plausible, meaningful. It is simply another way for designers to generate empathy with their users. It enables them to build up a cast of characters, socialised and known among the design team, in order to focus the team's design attention, to enable and contain design ideation, development action, testing, user acceptance, etc. A persona is employed as a shared sense making device, a fictional 'identity' or a character who is imagined in putative roles wherein some future version of the product is employed. These design strategies occupy the conceptual boundary between the design-world and the use-world. Each persona can be used to...

“Develop a precise description of our user and what he wishes to accomplish.” (Cooper, 2004) “Personas are not real people, but they are based on the behaviours and motivations of real people we have observed and represent them throughout the design process. They are composite archetypes based on behavioural data gathered from the many actual users encountered in ethnographic interviews.” (Cooper et al., 2007)

We can use “personas” or special classes of users as representative clients/user/consumers in order to overcome the impossibility of maintaining dialog with each and every participant.

Further reading

For example: Lee, online shopper with color blindness (link)

[Cooper, 2004] Cooper, A. (2004). The Inmates are Running the Asylum: Why High-Tech Products Drive Us Crazy and How to Restore the Sanity. Sams, Indianapolis, Indiana, USA.

[Cooper et al., 2007] Cooper, A., Reimann, R., and Cronin, D. (2007). About Face 3: The Essentials of Interaction Design. John Wiley & Sons, Indianapolis, Indiana.


Wednesday, April 14, 2021

From great ideas to game features

Maciej Szczesnik at GDC 13 on how The Witcher devs turn ideas into features

Source: video still from GDC 13

https://youtu.be/moW8-MXjivs

  • Ask questions about the feature (so you know what it could be)
  • Research research research
  • Talk with the team, brainstorm ideas, (the Crawford slip method - basically structured postit notes on a wall)
  • Innovation by reversal, contrasts, strange combinations.
  • Use measurable criteria and prioritisations
  • Does the idea cohere with the rest of the game?
  • Roadmap of ideas and stages so the plan can evolve
  • Continuously simplify so you can do more

Wednesday, April 7, 2021

A good lifecycle for organising game development?

I'll prefix this post by drawing your attention, to notice, that the title of this post makes no claim to this as the best lifecycle, method, or best practice. Rather, I posit that it could be a good practice, a good or useful lifecycle. Why am I careful to couch the claim in such diffident terms? Well, the industry has, certainly in the past, often been in thrall of various experts, consultancies and others, falsely claiming that there are best practices, world leading, methods or methodologies promising certainty and control of software development.

Mark Cerny started talking about and presenting his ideas for the "METHOD" process in 2002, hoping to spark debate about process failures surrounding game development, to address in some way the human cost, the damage to people's health, of "crunch" mode management, of death march projects, of sweatshop conditions in the studio system. Interest in the Method echoed a parallel movement in software engineering that sought to shift from dominant project management paradigms (linear, stepwise and waterfall methods), that led to the Agile Manifesto and Agile Methods becoming mainstream in the software industry.

Cerny wanted those funding the game publishing industry to acknowledge that more fluid process structures and practices were needed for video games. They needed a method that supported game design's highly creative but uncertain development processes. It was a provocation to manufacturers and publishers. It was also a response to the possibilities presented by the inevitable transformation happening in the market for video games, the move from a physical product manufacturing paradigm, to a virtual digital good and distribution paradigm, the move away from copies of 'finished products' to versions and downloadable releases.

Management is the art of organisational control, of minimising risk while maximising benefit. Management methods are organisational approach for producing goods of one kind or another, they are systems of risk management. Processes, lifecycles and methodologies, are attempts to make product design and development repeatable, sustainable, to deliver value. Like many in the business, Cerny thought that games are different. A hybrid of software engineering, artistic expression, and all the creative drive to produce something that is fun, playable, enjoyable, valuable. 

The METHOD is like developing two projects, back-to-back. The first version partial, incomplete, promising. The second version an evolution (perhaps even a revolution) of the first, expansive, complete, a full realisation of the game's potential. And so we organise our goals, teams and activities differently for the different stages of a game's development lifecycle. Pre-product yields a first playable version. Production delivers on that foundation, by scaling and elaborating on the original ideas. The first version is the proof of game, the 30% prototype. At this point we can put the core idea to the test. If it remains exciting, demonstrates its value, convinces us that there is a game and and audience, then yes, we go into production, we invest the 70% to bring it to production. 

"Pre-production" is vastly different from "production". Likewise, the kind of feedback that is useful between the two is different. Think of a small focused audience for the pre-production effort. Think of wider more intensive play-testing (even further discovery) in the build-out and polish of the later design/development process in production. And accept that changes, even significant changes may be needed, even at, what might be thought of as, the end of the lifecycle.

Cerny's METHOD

https://www.slideshare.net/holtt/cerny-method

Monday, April 5, 2021

6 short stories on how to fund your indie game

This post on the Unreal Engine blog presents 6 short stories on how ot fund your indie game project. All of the hint at the value of a working prototype, of asking for and listening to feedback, of using that feedback in some way, either responding and expanding or for analytical introspection of your project. Look for attention, look for interest, listen to the responses, respond honestly while respecting your vision.

Keeping the team as small and costs low for as long as possible.

Reuse whatever you can rather than creating new technologies. That way you'll be investing in realising your vision, the things that are unique to your game, rather than reinventing the building blocks. Build on the shoulders of giants. Along the way, by serendipity or discovery you may invent new, useful, general purpose technologies that are valuable and sellable, (well done if you do).

Make sure you can answer the question; how is your game going to make money?

Building something, even something small but tangible builds confidence and offers immense learning opportunities, both for the team's capabilities and how others perceive the sample.

Look for multiple lines of investment at the appropriate moment. Self-funded, friends and family, public agencies, investors...


https://www.unrealengine.com/en-US/blog/how-to-fund-your-indie-game

Monday, March 22, 2021

Editing mp3 files for a podcast

Audacity 3 (https://www.audacityteam.org)

Feel free to pick and choose from the general tips on editing mp3 files for a podcast below:

For sound engineering, I encourage you to record and post-edit your recording using the latest version of Audacity. 
Post-editing a recording enables you to tidy things up. Cutting gaps, reducing the 'emms and ahhs', remove filler speech, background noises and any generally unnecessary audio. Audacity also lets you to record directly to the project if needed for voice over and bookend statements.

You can also post-process the recording to try to improve its quality; applying effects such as normalize (e.g. default values, typical -2.5dB) and compressor (default values), noise reduction, to fade in / fade out edits and eventually, and then ultimately, export the finished project to a new mp3 file.



A screen shot of an Audacity project
A screen shot of an Audacity project

The screenshot above illustrates what waveform levels might look like for your recording. Above all else  trust your ears to judge the quality of a recording when you listen back to it.

Editing Audio for Podcasting with Audacity

Save Save Save - the Project file and folder

Everything lives in .aup3.
You are strongly advised NOT to save your active project to an external USB stick/disk, networked storage or cloud storage as it is unlikely to be fast enough for satisfactory recording and editing.

To avoid data loss save the project frequently. Make a local disk copy for project editing as Audacity generates very large sets of project edit/state files (online cloud drive services may not unpack or stage quickly enough to support Audacity's project edit/save cycle).
To share an Audacity project with others you will need to share the project aup3 file. 
n.b. older versions of Audacity stored data in a project _data folder.  If you move to Audacity 3 there will no longer be a _data folder for each project (yay).

Importing audio

Create a new project and save to disk.
    File > Save Project > Save Project (cmd S)
Import previously recorded audio (an mp3 or wav file). 
    File > Import > Audio
Save
    cmd S 
Your Audacity project with at least one audio track will resemble the screen shot above.
You can play, pause and even record new audio to the current track. 
The playhead is the vertical line displayed over the waveform. All tracks will play through the audio device unless muted or one is soloed. The keyboard space bar toggles the play/pause function from the current playhead.

Quick select, cut and paste

The Audacity toolbars, click and drag to rearrange or float

Choose the Selection Tool (F1) to edit your audio track directly. Click-drag to highlight parts of the audio waveform. Use the cursor to select the waveform to copy (cmd C), paste (cmd V), duplicate (cmd D) cut (cmd X) or delete (del, backspace or cmd K) along the timeline. The edit commands are also accessed via the menu.
    Edit > etc.

Using Tracks 

Import a second audio file (for example, our intro/outro music).
Save the project (you should save frequently).
You will see at least two tracks in the current Audacity window.
Toggle the Sync-Lock Tracks setting if you want multiple tracks to overlay each other. This is useful if for example you want to overlap and slowly fade out an intro jingle.
    Tracks > Sync-Lock Tracks (on/off)
You can organise the structure of a recording by using new tracks for sections of audio (to organise the large scale edit).

Large scale edit

Your listeners want a well edited informative podcast so remember, less is more. You will have to listen (and re-listen) to your material and decide what to keep or delete. Think about the length and structure of the recording. You can change the order. You will delete stuff so do it. Concentrate on large chunks, the structure of the talk. Don’t worry about breathing, coughs and minor noises just yet. 

Small scale edit

After the large scale edit more or less done, spend time on the small scale edit. This involves zooming in and fine-grained cut and pasting. But think before acting, is it really necessary to remove every single intake of breath? 
For example: cut long gaps, background noises and any generally unnecessary audio. You might also cut some of the egregious 'emms and ahhs' and nervous filler speech we all use. A caution though, the small scale edit can become a journey without an end, or at least a very long journey.
Note: "Sometimes you will not want to close the gap and yet still remove the noise, for instance if somebody breathes loudly. For such occasions copy a section of audio during which nobody is speaking (e.g. at the start of the recording) and paste it over the unwanted noise. This will preserve the natural pacing of speech." (source: Cook & Holdis, CEU Podcast Library - link)

Fade-in Fade-out

Apply fade-in and fade-out when you want the speech to start or end smoothly.


A useful Audacity EQ setting

Post-processing - Graphic EQ (equalization)

Base boost plust treble boost

Post-processing - normalize

Apply default (-3dB) - the waveform will push over 0.5 but keep away from 1.0

Post-processing - compressor

Choose a threshold between default -12dB down to as low as -30dB
Select noise floor, around -50dB
Ratio, between 2:1 - 3:1 - 5:1
Drop attack time (0.2s) and release time (2.0s) to maximise compression applied

These settings end up boosting the volume (visually the waveform moves closer to 1.0) making it too loud and noisy so you'll need to normalize (or amplify) again...

Post-processing - normalize again

Apply default (-3dB) or you can apply Amplify -3dB, for the same result. 
The desired result being for the waveform peaks to re-balance back to around the 0.5 level.

Post-processing - noise reduction (if needed)

Post-processing - low pass / high pass and other ways to reduce echo?

Export the mp3



Quality checks:

  • Is the intro/outro music at a suitable level?
  • Does the intro/outro transition smoothly to/from the spoken audio?
  • Is the spoken audio at a suitable level? (i.e. no clipping, waveform amplitude averages around 0.5 on linear scale)
  • Is the speed of speech natural?
  • Large scale edit - remove fumbled speech, removed confidential disclosures, cut out a duplicate or passages that were off topic, etc.
  • Small scale edit - remove ticks, emms, ahhs, sighs, distracting background, etc.

Useful links

An Audacity tutorial on mixing a narration with background music
https://manual.audacityteam.org/man/tutorial_mixing_a_narration_with_background_music.html

Refer to the Audacity manual online (e.g. the track panel description/explanation is at manual.audacityteam.org)

An Audacity user's simple tutorial and workflow activities:

Using the Compressor in Audacity

Using Noise Removal in Audacity

On including music from other artists (for atmosphere, decoratively, for intros/outros & transitions)

In the first instance, if you know the artist ask for their permission to use their material. You may be pleasantly surprised by the positive cycle of recognition and community surrounding artist works. Make sure you acknowledge them in your show notes.

We recommend releasing under the “Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike version 4.0  creative commons license (aka CC BY-NC-SA 4.0). You can choose from a number or variations of the CC license; CC BY, CC BY-NC, CC SA etc.
These licenses can be viewed at https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0

Always check the royalty free claims of audio samples found online. If you want to find audio from online sources, search for CC BY titles on Soundcloud or on YouTube
The link to the YouTube channel  "Of Musicians" below is a collection of a selection of royalty free original music.

Record the following information in your show notes to establish the provenance and bona fides of 3rd party music, artwork and creative content that you decide to use:

Music (CC BY-NC-SA license) 
Title: “a title”
Artist: “a name”
Source: “a link to the original”
License: “CC BY-NC-SA”

Cover Art (CC BY-NC-SA license)
Title: “a title”
Artist: “a name”
Source: “a link to the original”
License: “CC BY-NC-SA”



Wednesday, March 3, 2021

Articulate online?

Articulate has offered the cards online for people to play during the pandemic.



For a review and tips on the rules? https://youtu.be/xXMsP99edmY

A simplified version of the game board.


Monday, February 22, 2021

Audio recording: a statement on games and game design

Personal Reflection

A short self-recording of a statement on games and game design. Refer to the show notes below:

For this exercise you will create a short high quality audio recording, parts of which will be combined later with other student recordings and compiled into a single podcast episode to be published on Design Talk (dot IE). Record your voice only. Ensure your recording environment has little or no background noise. Leave gaps between statements to enable easy editing. Please do not add musical elements. Speak naturally, as if in conversation with someone. You may record in your preferred language but if so please provide a written english translation. The recording would be between 2 to 4 minutes long. 

Audacity (https://www.audacityteam.org)

I encourage you to record and post-edit your recording using Audacity. You will cut unnecessary audio, apply effects such as normalize (e.g. default values, typical -2.5dB) and compressor (default values), noise reduction, fade in / fade out etc. and export to an mp3 file.

Review the simple Audacity tutorial and workflow activities at:
https://podcasts.ceu.edu/how-edit-your-podcast-audacity-step-step-guide

A screen shot of an Audacity project
A screen shot of an Audacity project

Refer above to the screen shot to get an idea of what nice waveform levels might look like for your recording. However, above all, trust your ears to judge the quality of a recording when you listen back to it.

Show notes

(introduce yourself, first-name only is sufficient)
(create your own statement or adapt one or more of the following opening sentences) 

  • Hi, I'm <Name>.
  • For me games are ...
  • My best memory ...
  • Game design is ...
  • The thing we could do better ...
  • Good game design can change the world by ...

Terms and conditions

The `Design Talk (dot IE)’ podcasts are released under the “Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike version 4.0  creative commons license (aka CC BY-NC-SA 4.0)

This license can be viewed at https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0

By taking part you are entering a verbal agreement giving permission for your voice to be recorded, for the recording to be edited, for it to be posted and published and available from wherever people get their podcasts.


Monday, February 15, 2021

Play games, lots and lots of games

To quote Katie Salen Tekinbaş and Eric Zimmerman, the authors of Rules of Play (2004)...

"...it is incredibly important that game design students play games, lots and lots of them. Students should play every possible kind of game, digital and non-digital, contemporary and historical, masterpiece and stinker. Game design students play these games in order to cultivate a historical awareness and critical sensitivity about the kinds of games that have already been designed, to learn how games function to create experiences, and to discover what does and doesn't work about particular design choices." (Salen Tekinbaş and Zimmerman: p20, 2004)

Playing games is the kind of homework I wish I had been set. The following selection from Evan Leed's compilation (2020)

Deduction Games

  • Codenames - See CodenamesGame.com the official site. Share link, no sign up involved. No cheating possible (can’t peak at key card).


Drawing Games

  • Telestrations. Sketch what you see and guess what you saw. Quick intro videos short intro - https://youtu.be/Hcdj4GO16IA or long intro - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhAQg05M4ww
    • DrawPhone.tannerkrewson.com Simple, just share game code. Can adjust timer, can’t draw in colour.
    • brokenpicturephone.com (Broken picture phone) Simple, share room code. No timer, people’s “books” visible backlog.


Word Games

  • Just One - see OneWord.games. Share room name. Don’t have to sign up.
  • Articulate - cards online for people to play during the pandemic


Sunday, February 14, 2021

Improv exercise: rule trees

(A game properties improv exercise adapted from Salen Tekinbaş & Zimmerman (2004))

Rule Trees - a collaborative exercise for creating linked and branching rule sets. 

  1. First person writes 2 game rule statements. The first rule is covered.
  2. Only reveal the last (new) rule to the next person.
  3. Second person writes 2 additional game rule statements based on viewing the last rule (above), 
  4. Only reveal the last (new) rule to the next person.
  5. Third person writes 2 additional game rule statements based on viewing the last rule (above), 
  6. Only reveal the last (new) rule to the next person.
  7. <repeat>
  8. The last person adds a win condition.
  9. The group reviews the 'rules and win' and fashions a game from them.


References:

Salen, K., Tekinbaş, K.S. and Zimmerman, E., 2004. Rules of play: Game design fundamentals. MIT press.


Wednesday, February 10, 2021

Monopoly's unlikely and ironic history

Long story short. 

"In 1903, a leftwing feminist called Lizzy Magie patented the board game that we now know as Monopoly – but she never gets the credit"

Check out the secret history of monopoly (www.theguardian.com)

Nostalgia, challenge, confronting, or pure playability, 4 games I would/will play again (2021)

We ask ourselves about the reasons behind why we play or would play each of these games again (and again).

From the 2021 class:

Boardgame

"I Doubt It" - cheating card game
Werewolf Kill
Rummikub
Dungeons & Dragons (D&D)
Monopoly x3
Snakes and ladders
Chess x2
"Man, don’t get angry"
UNO
Cards Against Humanity

Sport

Badminton x3
Snowboarding
Fencing
Volleyball
Soccer/Football x2
Rugby
Basketball
Running
"Lonely Mountains: Downhill" bicycle simulator
Padel

Videogame

Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
QQ Dizzal Dance  -
Counter-Strike Global Offensive
DOTA
Animal Crossing
Mass Effect Trilogy
Minecraft
FIFA
Apex Legends
"Detroit become human"
The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Stardew Valley
"Humanity Disappeared"
Super Mario Galaxy
League of Legends

Gamification

Coffee stamp card
Starbucks card/rewards app x2
Burger King Crowns
Simulate the stock market
Nike Fuel
Investopedia market simulator
Raffles
McDonalds coffee cup stickers
Duolingo
Insomnia coffee stamps
Codecademy
Google Maps - Google Guide
Twitch

Monday, February 8, 2021

Exercise: Definition of Game

What is a game? The metaphysics of games.

What is a game?
When is a game?
Why is a game?
Who is etc.

(Google Jamboard - access via @ucdconnect account)

(in breakout room)
Scroll to the Jamboard for your breakout room number
Brainstorm definitions and characteristics of games.


This exercise starts the process of game thinking and leads into the project of devising a game concept.
Use the basic shared whiteboard (Google Jamboard).
Respond to the prompts and add information to the Jamboard - this is a time limited activity.

10' introduction
15' breakout room activity
5' debrief

Lecturer points: If needed can seed topics for student concept maps:

Initial conditions; rules; rewards; goals; end-game states; win/lose states; voluntary; cooperative; competitive; constructive; destructive; payouts; motivation-intrinsic; motivation-extrinsic; the Magic Circle; puzzle; joy; fun.

Conclude by filling in the following survey:

https://docs.google.com/forms/ Game Thinking Questions


Wednesday, February 3, 2021

What does a game designer do?

What does a game designer do? I mean, isn't it obvious? Aren't they artists or coders? Don't they write and 'design'?

The Door Problem (Liz England post on the Gamasutra blog)

(a post on Gamasutra recommended by John-Patrick Molloy)


Doors in Dublin (Lesson St). Image by Ron Cogswell - CC BY 2.0


And while Liz England offers the door as a metaphorical lens on the work of the game designer, doors are also one of the most ubiquitous design elements in their own right. Every building, entrance and passage involves a door of some kind, a portal between one place and the next. Each level (or dungeon) is connected to another in some way, often by a door. The appearance and operation of in-game doors are crucial. How they look, sound and work can reinforce the player's experience of "game flow" as much as interfere with it. There is much that the game designer needs to get right. Megan Farokhmanesh's article on The Verge "Why Game Developers Can't Get a Handle on Doors" further explores the challenges of doors, observing that the simplest objects are sometimes the most difficult to design.

https://www.theverge.com/22328169/game-development-doors-design-difficult